Earlier today, a notice was given that two members of the committee would pose questions to the President focusing on the treatment of Hegde and the committee in general. These questions were to be posed to the President, understood to have meant to take place prior to the Thursday Debate.
Shortly after the Public Business Meeting began at 8:30 PM, and before any questions were posed about the treatment of Hegde, the President paused the meeting and proceeded to move directly on to the Thursday Debate. The meeting was adjourned as a member of the Oxford Union stood up in the chamber and moved the procedural motion “that Private Business be postponed.” The President passed this without a vote.
At this point, a disagreement broke out in the chamber. An elected Member of the Secretary’s Committee, Joe Murray, Pembroke College, stood up and shouted “On what grounds?” The President proceeded without acknowledging Murray.
Disha Hegde herself then voiced her discontent: “You are suppressing the members’ right to speech.’
As the President attempted to control the chamber a member of the Oxford Union Committee shouted “You bully Committee!”
The walkout seemed to follow growing discontent with the President, according to some protesters who spoke to The Oxford Student. “I walked out with Disha Hegde because I think it’s frankly ludicrous that her offer for paper speech was rescinded at the last minute by a bullying president,” said one member of the Union.
One member of the committee, who wished to remain anonymous, summarised their grievances to the Oxford Student: “If this happened three or four days ago, and there was enough advance warning given to Ms. Hegde, that would have been perfectly reasonable, because mistakes, bureaucratic or otherwise, do happen. It was sprung upon her [at] 1 a.m. of the same day, literally 15-16 hours before the actual thing [debate] happened. And I think that’s the basic problem, is that there was no advance warning… The fact that it was taken away from her [at the] last minute, when plans were already made, placed an undue burden upon her…I think that is so unfair and unprofessional.”
In the words of one attendee, “Work should be done to make the union a true place for debating, full stop.”
The Oxford Student has reached out for comment from Disha Hegde, Joe Murray, and The President of the Union. As of 10:30 PM, they have not responded to this request.
Image Credit: Jason Chau Image Description: The Oxford Union Debate Chamber